A traditional ideation tool is pen or pencil. In the digital age, however, the sketch can be hand-drawn either on paper or a digital device. Still the underlying technique, or style of drawing, or writing by hand reveals traditions and school curricula, also known as penmanship. For example, the traditional brush calligraphy, or lettering art, which is a fine visual art form is commonly prescribed in Asian schools although the curricula separate everyday handwriting from artistic brushwork. Yet by mandating calligraphy, Asian schools emphasise cultural heritage, building patience and teaching proper character structure. Interestingly, in UK design education, which attracts many international students, Asian students often stand out in their artful penmanship when compared to their British-schooled peers who often lack the skills of sketching, and whether artistically or by observation. This is mainly due to lack of practice that reflects the marginalisation of art and creative subjects in UK state schools. But the use of digital tools in educational settings is a global phenomenon, a trend which favours screen-based work and keyboard proficiency. And so, in China, for example, regular calligraphy practice is being pared down.
Monday, October 26, 2026
Sunday, October 11, 2026
GenAI storming
GenAI models, such as ChatGPT and Midjourney, have become ubiquitous in design education, across disciplines and year-levels. But whereas the Polyannas may hail GenAI as a modern deus ex machina, and "AI Doomsters" warn of a sci-fi style global takeover, a more sensible and pragmatic approach is that GenAI can be a tool for broad ideation expanding conceptual horizons while reducing time spent on routine or repetitive tasks like drafting, organising or summarising research data. Yet while GenAI models, which uses a top-down predictive approach with no true domain understanding, can offer students lots of creative ideas, GenAI also leads to concerns over plagiarism, that is, output without critical verification as copyrighted material is being used to train AI models without permission. Moreover, from a learning perspective, as tutors are increasingly using GenAI for teaching and assessment purposes, GenAI raises ethical issues that impact the tutor-student relationship. How, then, and to use academic jargon, to assess accurately the learner's procedural knowledge ("knowing how"), conditional knowledge ("knowing when, where and why") rather than just declarative knowledge ("knowing that"). That is, what proof that the student not only have "tool competency" (knowing that) but also "comprehensive competency" (knowing how and why)? This dilemma suggests assessment in the age of AI has become a wicked problem, that is, a problem that resists clear definition, is on-going and involves ethical trade-offs. Although individual's practice and experience of GenAI differ, in an increasingly corporate-driven educational environment influenced by high stakes social media, GenAI reveals new relationships between students as service recipients, tutors as delivery partners, and faculty as delivery organisation. And so, in this brave new AI world, where do knowledge and authenticity reside, and what is being evaluated or valued?